Item from the CAT | BAT-Back | PaBS | TIPPA | |
---|---|---|---|---|
1 | If human subjects were used, did the authors give a detailed description of the sample of subjects used to perform the (index) test? | Yes | Yes | No |
2 | Did the authors clarify the qualification, or competence of the rater(s) who performed the (index) test? | No | Yes | No |
4 | If interrater reliability was tested, were raters blinded to the findings of other raters? | No | Yes | No |
5 | If intrarater reliability was tested, were raters blinded to their own prior findings of the test under evaluation? | n/a | Yes | n/a |
6 | Was the order of examination varied? | n/a | No | n/a |
8 | Was the stability (or theoretical stability) of the variable being measured taken into account when determining the suitability of the time interval between repeated measures? | n/a | No | n/a |
10 | Was the execution of the (index) test described in sufficient detail to permit replication of the test? | Yes | Yes | No |
12 | Were withdrawals from the study explained? | Yes | Yes | Yes |
13 | Were the statistical methods appropriate for the purpose of the study? | Yes | Yes | No |
Ratio between the number of items with a positive answer and the total number of “applicable” items | 4/6 | 7/9 | 1/6 | |
Percentage | 66.7% | 77.8% | 16.7% | |
Decision before extraction | Retain | Retain | Reject |