Skip to main content

Table 5 Items 14-43: Ranking of the responses of the total cohort and WP Regions based on M (±SD), N (population) and % of Agree, Neutral and Disagree Responses

From: Views of physiotherapists on factors that play a role in ethical decision-making: an international online survey study

 

Total

WP Regions

Item

Description

N

M (±SD)

Rank

 

Africa

Asia West Pacific

Europe

North Amer Caribbean

South America

N

%

N

%

N

%

N

%

N

%

N

%

Agree

Agree

Agree

Agree

Agree

Agree

Neutral

Neutral

Neutral

Neutral

Neutral

Neutral

Disagree

Disagree

Disagree

Disagree

Disagree

Disagree

36

Physiotherapists need to behave ethically because it is socially expected as their professional role

415

4.26 (±0.74)

1

372

89.6

46

97.9

97

90.7

182

88.8

41

85.4

6

75.0

32

7.7

1

2.1

4

3.7

20

9.8

6

12.5

1

12.5

11

2.7

0

0

6

5.6

3

1.5

1

2.1

1

12.5

27

Ethical decision-making requires more skills than just observing a code of conduct or ethical principles

450

4.23 (±0.69)

2

412

91.6

45

91.8

111

93.3

197

90.0

49

92.5

10

100

30

6.7

4

8.2

6

5.0

18

8.2

2

3.8

0

0

8

1.8

0

0

2

1.7

4

1.8

2

3.8

0

0

34

A recognisable organisational culture of ethical practice can help a physiotherapist to make a good ethical decision

415

4.19 (±0.75)

3

368

88.7

43

91.5

98

91.6

180

87.8

40

83.3

7

87.5

36

6.5

3

6.4

5

4.7

23

11.2

4

8.3

1

12.5

11

2.7

1

2.1

4

3.7

2

1.0

4

8.3

0

0

35

How senior physiotherapists represent their profession influences the attitude of junior physiotherapists in a good or bad manner

415

4.16 (±0.81)

4

355

85.5

41

87.2

96

89.7

167

81.5

43

89.6

8

100

42

10.1

5

10.6

10

9.3

24

11.7

3

6.3

0

0

18

4.3

1

2.1

1

0.9

14

6.8

2

4.2

0

0

21

In ethical decision-making I consider my professional obligations

450

4.12 (±0.68)

5

399

88.7

47

95.9

98

82.4

194

88.6

51

96.2

9

90.0

41

9.1

1

2.0

17

14.3

21

9.6

1

1.9

1

10.0

10

2.2

1

2.0

4

3.4

4

1.8

1

1.9

0

0

14

I can recognise a professional ethical situation

450

4.07 (±0.58)

6

402

89.3

46

93.9

105

88.2

191

87.2

50

94.3

10

100

43

9.6

3

6.1

13

10.9

25

11.4

2

3.8

0

0

5

1.1

0

0

1

0.8

3

1.4

1

1.9

0

0

32

Unethical behaviour increases where it stays unpunished

415

4.05 (±0.94)

7

324

78.3

43

91.5

95

88.8

139

67.8

40

83.3

8

100

57

13.7

3

6.4

8

7.5

42

20.5

4

8.3

0

0

33

8.0

1

2.1

4

3.7

24

11.7

4

8.3

0

0

22

In ethical decision-making I consider the viewpoints of all involved persons or/and facilities

450

4.04 (±0.70)

8

397

88.2

45

91.8

107

89.9

193

88.1

44

83.0

8

80.0

34

7.6

1

2.0

8

6.7

19

8.7

5

9.4

1

10.0

19

4.2

3

6.1

4

3.4

7

3.2

4

7.5

1

10.0

39

Healthcare system conditions can limit or permit unethical practices

415

3.90 (±0.92)

9

323

77.8

44

93.6

83

77.6

147

71.7

41

85.4

8

100

50

12.0

1

2.1

14

13.1

32

15.6

3

6.3

0

0

42

10.1

2

4.3

10

9.3

26

12.7

4

8.3

0

0

15

I can analyse and describe a professional ethical situation

450

3.87 (±0.70)

10

359

79.8

38

77.6

100

84.0

166

75.8

46

86.8

9

90.0

69

12.4

7

14.3

15

12.6

41

18.7

5

9.4

1

10.0

22

4.9

4

8.2

4

3.4

12

5.5

2

3.8

0

0

17

I can describe the difference between personal morality and professional ethics

450

3.86 (±0.84)

11

356

79.1

41

83.7

100

84.0

163

74.4

44

83.0

8

80.0

51

11.3

5

10.2

11

9.2

29

13.2

6

11.3

0

0

43

9.6

3

6.1

8

6.7

27

12.3

3

5.7

2

20.0

40

Contextual factors* can act as barriers or resources to ethical decision-making

(Characteristics unique to a particular situation, e.g., geographical location and setting, economic factors, resource pressures, institutional context, payment mechanisms)

415

3.81 (±0.85)

12

313

75.4

40

85.1

80

74.8

150

73.2

38

79.2

5

62.5

64

15.4

4

8.5

17

15.9

35

17.1

5

10.4

3

37.5

38

9.2

3

6.4

10

9.3

20

9.8

5

10.4

0

0

29

My personal values play a role in ethical decision-making

450

3.77 (±0.96)

13

322

71.6

34

69.4

84

70.6

159

72.6

38

71.7

7

70.0

76

16.9

9

18.4

24

20.2

33

15.1

7

13.2

3

30.0

52

11.6

6

12.2

11

9.2

27

12.3

8

15.1

0

0

43

Possible consequences of the decision play a role in my ethical decision-making

415

3.76 (±0.92)

14.5

303

73.0

37

78.7

79

73.8

149

72.7

32

66.7

6

75.0

59

14.2

6

12.8

18

16.8

30

14.6

5

10.4

0

0

53

12.8

4

8.5

10

9.3

26

12.7

11

22.9

2

25.0

18

I feel competent when I need to make a professional ethical-decision

450

3.76 (±0.82)

14.5

319

70.9

32

65.3

85

71.4

148

67.6

45

84.9

9

90.0

97

21.6

13

26.5

23

19.3

54

24.7

6

11.3

1

10.0

34

7.6

4

8.2

11

9.2

17

7.8

2

3.8

0

0

28

I have the ability to deal with uncertainty in an ethical situation

450

3.71 (±0.75)

16

315

70.0

33

67.3

86

72.3

145

66.2

44

83.0

7

70.0

105

23.3

10

20.4

27

22.7

62

28.3

5

9.4

1

10.0

30

6.7

6

12.2

6

5.0

12

5.5

4

7.5

2

20.0

16

I know the code of ethics for physiotherapists of the country I work in

449

3.70 (±0.95)

17

324

72.2

38

77.6

93

78.2

142

65.1

44

83.0

7

70.0

58

12.9

6

12.2

11

9.2

36

16.5

4

7.5

1

10.0

67

14.9

5

10.2

15

12.6

40

18.3

5

9.4

2

20.0

41

Cultural factors of the country I work in play a role in my ethical decision-making

415

3.60 (±1.03)

18

269

64.8

37

78.7

80

74.8

117

57.1

30

62.5

5

62.5

70

16.9

7

14.9

13

12.1

41

20.0

8

16.7

1

12.5

76

18.3

3

6.4

14

13.1

47

22.9

10

20.8

2

25.0

38

Ethical decision-making is more difficult when the factors that contribute to the situation are outside of the realm of my influence

415

3.56 (±0.95)

19

265

63.9

33

70.2

71

66.4

125

61.0

32

66.7

4

50.0

77

13.9

6

12.8

22

20.6

41

20.0

6

12.5

2

25.0

73

17.6

8

17.0

14

13.1

39

19.0

10

20.8

2

25.0

31

Bureaucracy tends to make physiotherapists to follow rules and obligations rather than to think independently about ethical decision-making

415

3.49 (±0.97)

20

232

55.9

29

61.7

60

56.1

111

54.1

26

54.2

6

75.0

110

26.5

10

21.3

31

29.0

52

25.4

16

33.3

1

12.5

73

17.6

8

17.0

16

15.0

42

20.5

6

12.5

1

12.5

37

When ethical behaviour is compromised regularly by a physiotherapist other colleagues will tend to also behave less ethically

415

3.45 (±1.04)

21

230

55.4

27

57.4

74

69.2

91

44.4

31

64.6

7

87.5

90

21.7

9

19.1

11

10.3

61

29.8

8

16.7

1

12.5

95

22.9

11

23.4

22

20.6

53

25.9

9

18.8

0

0

42

The type/kind of an ethical situation plays a role in my ethical decision-making (E.g., an ethical dilemma between competing principles which both seem to be right, a distress of which course of action to take, a temptation of choosing between ‘right’ and ‘wrong’ when you would benefit from doing the wrong thing, remaining silent in a situation which appears to be too difficult to be resolved)

414

3.38 (±0.94)

22.5

233

56.3

23

48.9

63

58.9

113

55.4

30

62.5

4

50.0

95

22.9

12

25.5

21

19.6

51

25.0

11

22.9

0

0

86

20.8

12

25.5

23

21.5

40

19.6

7

14.6

4

50.0

30

Contextual factors of the working system play a role in my ethical decision-making (Characteristics unique to a particular situation, e.g., setting, economic factors, competitive behaviour, resource pressures, institutional context)

415

3.38 (±1.00)

22.5

229

55.2

34

72.3

64

59.8

104

50.7

24

50.0

3

37.5

87

21.0

5

10.6

22

20.6

47

22.9

11

22.9

2

25.0

99

23.9

8

17.0

21

19.6

54

26.3

13

27.1

3

37.5

24

My gut-feelings play a role in ethical decision-making

450

3.37 (±1.00)

24.5

247

54.9

23

46.9

60

50.4

128

58.4

28

52.8

8

80.0

105

23.3

15

30.6

26

21.8

51

23.3

13

24.5

0

0

98

21.8

11

22.4

33

27.7

40

18.3

12

22.6

2

20.0

19

I refer to a professional framework for ethical decision-making

450

3. 37 (±0.99)

24.5

239

53.1

32

65.3

79

66.4

97

44.3

24

45.3

7

70.0

115

25.6

10

20.4

28

21.8

66

30.1

10

18.9

3

30.0

96

21.3

7

14.3

14

11.8

56

25.6

19

35.8

0

0

26

My emotions play a role in ethical decision-making

450

2.95 (±1.03)

26

163

36.2

12

24.5

34

28.6

95

43.4

19

35.8

3

30.0

112

24.9

10

20.4

31

26.1

52

23.7

15

28.3

4

40.0

175

38.9

27

55.1

54

45.4

72

32.9

19

35.8

3

30.0

25

The ethics education in my basic physiotherapy training provided a solid foundation for ethical decision-making (depending on the country this could be Bachelor’s degree,

Diploma, Physiotherapy school, in some countries the profession’s entry level is Master’s degree or Professional doctorate)

450

2.90 (±1.14)

27

167

37.1

24

49.0

58

48.7

50

22.8

31

58.5

4

40.0

101

22.4

9

18.4

26

21.8

55

25.1

9

17.0

2

20.0

182

40.4

16

32.7

35

29.4

114

52.1

13

24.5

4

40.0

23

Ethical decision-making stresses me out

450

2.77 (±1.00)

28

118

21.3

11

22.4

34

28.6

55

25.1

14

26.4

4

40.0

132

29.3

11

22.4

37

31.1

64

29.2

16

30.2

4

40.0

200

44.4

27

55.1

48

40.3

100

45.7

23

43.4

2

20.0

33

Organisational values have greater influence on my ethical decision-making than my own considerations

415

2.71 (±1.04)

29

104

25.1

18

38.3

38

35.5

40

19.5

6

12.5

2

25.0

106

25.5

12

25.5

30

28.0

52

25.4

11

22.9

1

12.5

205

49.1

17

36.2

39

36.4

113

55.1

31

64.6

5

62.5

20

My religious beliefs play a role in ethical decision-making

450

2.54 (±1.27)

30

119

26.4

22

44.9

41

34.5

42

19.2

13

24.5

1

10.0

94

20.9

14

28.6

23

19.3

42

19.2

14

26.4

1

10.0

237

52.7

13

26.5

55

48.2

135

61.6

26

49.1

8

80.0