Skip to main content

Table 2 First step of the critical appraise: clinical criteria appraisal

From: How to objectively assess and observe maladaptive pain behaviors in clinical rehabilitation: a systematic search and review

Method

Time to complete

≤ 10 min OR ≤ 30 min if part of a comprehensive assessment

Scoring method

Not videotaped

Interpretation

Does the method propose an interpretation of the score (severity, …)?

No special equipment required

Decision

(retain or reject)

Aung’s method [26]

We can assume < 10 min

Reject

Behavioral Avoidance Test-Back Pain (BAT-Back)

[27]

< 10 min

Specific rating according to the level of avoidance

Range of possible scores is 0 to 60

(0 = no avoidance, 60 = every movement is avoided)

Retain

Butler and Kozey’s method [28]

We can assume < 10 min

Reject

Cinciripini’s method [29]

We can assume < 10 min

Reject

Cold pressure method [30]

2-min

Reject

Keefe and Block [31] (K&B) and modified K&B [32]

10-min

Reject

Keefe’s walk method [33]

We can assume < 10 min

Reject

Koho’s method [34]

We can assume > 10 min

Reject

Moores’ method [35]

We can assume > 10 min

Frequencies of PB

Reject

Pain Behaviour Scale (PaBS) [36]

Part of a physical performance test of 10 to 15 min

Frequencies of PB

A total score of severity can be determined from 0 to 15

Retain

Prkachin’s method [18]

Number of PB

Reject

Test Instrument for Profile of Physical Ability (TIPPA) [37]

Part of a comprehensive assessment but we can assume < 30 min

Presence of PB

A severity scale is proposed based on the number of activities with PBs

Retain

Thieme’s method [38]

8-min

Reject

Watson’s method [39]

We can assume > 10 min

Reject

  1. : unclear
  2. : no
  3. : yes